Skip to main content
ScribNet

Cybersecurity

What Your Cyber Insurance Questionnaire Is Really Asking

A plain-English guide to the questions on a cyber insurance application, what each one means for a small office, and how to answer honestly.

6 min read

If you have ever opened a cyber insurance application, you know the feeling. Page after page of yes-or-no questions, most of them written in undecipherable tech jargon. Do you enforce multi-factor authentication? Are your backups immutable? Is your endpoint detection managed?

While it is tempting to answer “yes” to every question, that can be a costly mistake. These questionnaires are not just a formality; they are the insurer’s method of determining your company’s overall security stance and evaluating their overall risk exposure by insuring you. Incorrect or inaccurate answers can result in your insurance company denying your claim, making an already bad situation even worse.

This guide walks through the typical questions in plain English: what the insurer is trying to learn, what a careful answer looks like for an office of 10 to 30 people, and where owners tend to get tripped up. Every insurer words things differently, so treat this as a translation guide, not a copy of any one form. We can help you answer accurately and fix any security gaps. While the final decision of whether to honor a claim belongs to the insurance company, a properly filled out cyber insurance questionnaire, together with properly implemented security and disaster recovery technologies, can make a positive outcome more likely.

Multi-factor authentication

What they ask: “Do you require multi-factor authentication (MFA) for email, remote access and administrator accounts?”

What it means: Beyond entering a password, MFA requires additional identity verification before you can access a secured resource, such as email or a VPN. The additional step could be an SMS (text) code or a prompt sent to your smartphone. If a password is stolen, the thief still can’t get in.

Where answers go wrong: “Required” and “available” are different things. If MFA is turned on for the owner but optional for everyone else, or covers email but not remote access methods, the honest answer is not a yes. Check the settings in your email system and your remote access methods, then look at who and what is actually covered. For more on sign-in options, see our posts on password managers and passwordless logins.

Backups

What they ask: “Do you back up critical data? Are backups stored offline or separate from your network? Do you perform test restores of your backup images?”

What it means: The insurer wants to know that if files are encrypted or deleted, you have another copy that the attacker could not reach, and that someone has tried getting data back from it.

Where answers go wrong: Having a backup is not the same as being able to restore from it. A copy that sits on the same network, or is reachable with the same login, can be damaged along with everything else. Cloud accounts such as Microsoft 365 and Google Workspace are also easy to forget when people say, “We back up the server.” It’s important to confirm that your current IT provider is testing your backups, and how often. If the answer is insufficient, say so on the form and get it fixed as soon as possible. Our overview of IT disaster recovery explains the basics.

Software updates and patching

What they ask: “Do you apply security updates on a regular schedule? Do you run any software that the maker no longer supports?”

What it means: Attackers go after known weaknesses that already have a fix. The insurer wants to see that updates are applied on a routine basis, not whenever someone remembers.

Where answers go wrong: The usual surprise is the old machine in the corner: a server, a printer, or a business application that nobody wants to touch. If it no longer gets patches and updates from its manufacturer, you need to document it on the form. We can help figure out ways to minimize its security exposure. The best practice is to first compile a list of every computer, server and network device in your office. You cannot answer a patching question about equipment you have not counted.

Protection on computers

What they ask: “Do you use endpoint protection on all devices? Is it monitored?”

What it means: “Endpoint” means laptops, desktops and servers. The insurer wants security software on each device, and someone actively monitoring and reacting if it raises an alarm.

Where answers go wrong: Software installed on most machines is not “all devices.” Personal laptops, a spare PC in the break room, or a new hire’s computer that was never set up properly are the usual gaps. Monitored means a person or service is actively watching for alerts, not just that software is installed.

Who has access to what

What they ask: “Do you limit administrator rights? Do you remove access when employees leave?”

What it means: The fewer people who can change anything, the less damage one stolen account can do. And a former employee’s account should not still have access after they are no longer with your company.

Where answers go wrong: In the past, it was standard practice for everyone to have administrative rights on their workstations, because it streamlined software and device installation. Nowadays, it is a major security hole. Departing staff are also easy to miss when no one owns the offboarding list. If you pull up your list of current users and there are some that you don’t recognize, you could have a big problem.

Staff security training

What they ask: “Do employees receive security awareness training? How often? Do you test them with phishing simulations?”

What it means: Many attacks start with a person clicking a link or answering a fake request. The insurer wants evidence that your staff have been taught what to look for.

Where answers go wrong: A one-time discussion when onboarding a new employee does not constitute an ongoing program. Insurers want to know that there is regular training. As the insured, you should keep a simple record of what each training covers, how often it happens and who attended. We write more about why this starts with the owner in cybersecurity education for your team.

An incident response plan

What they ask: “Do you have a written plan for responding to a cyber incident? Is it tested?”

What it means: Your insurer wants to know that if something does happen, you already have a plan of action to minimize the impact as quickly as possible. When something goes wrong, who makes the first call, who decides what gets shut off, and who contacts the insurer? The answers to all these questions should already be known. No guesswork, just action.

Where answers go wrong: Many businesses have a plan that lives in one person’s head. The plan should be a physical document that lays everything out in an easy-to-follow, organized fashion. A well-thought-out plan can be a lifesaver in an incredibly stressful event. But even a short, written page with phone numbers, who to call first, and where the backups are kept is better than nothing, and it is a real answer.

Rules that apply to your industry

Some questionnaires also ask about regulated data, such as health records or payment cards. If that applies to you, our HIPAA and PCI-DSS guide and our post on IT compliance for insurance companies cover the ground. We help with risk assessments, policies, documentation and staff training. We do not certify anyone.

How to answer honestly

  • Check before you tick. For each question, find the setting or the list that proves the answer.
  • Write “partly” when it is partly. An accurate answer with a plan to close the gap is safer than a confident yes that falls apart later.
  • Ask who signs. The person who signs the application is attesting to the answers, so give them time to review.
  • Start before renewal week. Fixes such as turning on MFA for everyone take days, not minutes.

Not sure how you would answer?

Our cybersecurity service covers the tools and habits these questions point at: sign-in protection, backup, updates, monitored protection and staff training. If an application is on your desk and you want a second pair of eyes before you sign, call us at 804-773-7090 or use the contact form. We can help you through the process without the technical jargon.

Questions About This? Talk to ScribNet

Tell us what you are working with and we will get back to you. Prefer to talk? Call 804-773-7090.

Fields marked required must be filled in.

Tell us a little about your business and what you are trying to solve.

By sending this form you agree to our privacy policy.

Keep Reading

All Articles